The story behind the agricultural center becoming a living museum is connected to the county's segregated past and the development that would become the City of Palm Coast which began with the fire that destroyed Bunnell High School in the early morning in July 1970. After the fire, George Washington Carver High School, a formerly segregated school that closed in 1967, reopened for displaced students from Bunnell until 1974, when a new school was built.
After the fire, local officials had to make a decision to either rebuild the school on the original site or build the new one at a different location. At that time, ITT Community Development Corporation was in the process of creating Palm Coast and offered the district a free parcel of land on State Road 100 with the condition that the new school be named Flagler-Palm Coast High School.
Unfortunately, during this time, the Little Red School House experienced a period of decline and fell into disrepair. In 1987, after years of being boarded up and sitting in neglect, a plan was put forth to the Flagler County School Board to restore the Vocational Agricultural Building by a group of advocates for the "Little Red School House." The group was headed up by Marquis, Latham, and Brown and formed the "Friends of the Little Red School House."
With a Parent Teacher Association donation, the Friends of the Little Red School House were able to hire an architect to assess the condition of the building. The project took seven years to complete through bake sales, quilt sales, donations, and any other thing they could think of to raise funds and awareness. Everything came to fruition in 1992 with a $10,000 Blueprint grant from the Florida Legislature. On November 15, 1993, the building was officially dedicated as the Little Red School House Museum.